Misfits Market vs Hungry Harvest vs Farmbox Direct — Our Pick: Misfits Market
Latest Update
Updated for 2025 Grocery delivery • Food waste • Ugly produce New to food boxes & meal planners

Misfits Market vs Hungry Harvest vs Farmbox Direct

We compared availability, product selection, pricing, and food-waste impact. Our pick: Misfits Market for the best overall balance of nationwide reach, variety, and savings.

Best overall grocery box

Why we prefer Misfits Market

  • Nationwide online grocery with rescued produce, pantry staples, meat, dairy, snacks, and more.
  • Serves nearly every ZIP code in the contiguous U.S., so most households can use it.
  • Flexible ordering windows, low order minimum, and free shipping above a spending threshold.
  • Strong sustainability mission: rescues “imperfect” or surplus food and partners with food banks.
Heads-up: Want a smaller, more regional service with a big focus on donations? Hungry Harvest shines if you’re in its East Coast delivery area. Prefer a classic farm-box experience with organic and all-natural options? Farmbox Direct is a good fit.

At a glance

Misfits Market

Best overall

Top pick for the strongest mix of nationwide availability, deep grocery selection, and rescued-food savings.

  • Nationwide delivery across most of the contiguous U.S.
  • Huge catalog: organic produce, pantry items, meat, dairy, snacks, and more
  • Rescues “imperfect” and surplus groceries to fight food waste
Shop Misfits Market

Hungry Harvest

Best local impact

Regional rescued-produce service with a strong hunger-relief mission and thoughtfully sized weekly or biweekly boxes.

  • Produce-first boxes in multiple sizes, with organic options
  • Delivers to select East Coast and Midwest areas
  • Each delivery rescues produce and supports hunger-fighting organizations
Explore Hungry Harvest

Farmbox Direct

Best classic farm box

Nationwide farm-box style subscription with organic and all-natural options that feels like a farmers’ market at your door.

  • Weekly boxes of mixed fruits and veggies shipped across most of the U.S.
  • Choose organic or all-natural, plus fruit-only, veg-only, and juicing boxes
  • Customize contents with substitutions and flexible delivery schedules
See Farmbox Direct
What to compare Misfits Market Hungry Harvest Farmbox Direct
Primary strength Best overall: nationwide rescued-grocery marketplace Regional food-waste fighter with strong local donations Classic farm-box style produce subscription
Availability Serves nearly every ZIP code in the contiguous U.S. Limited to select East Coast & Midwest metro areas Ships produce boxes to most addresses in the continental U.S.
Product focus Rescued organic produce plus full grocery selection (pantry, meat, dairy, snacks, wine) Rescued fruits & veggies first, with some add-on grocery staples Curated boxes of fruits and vegetables; some juicing-specific boxes
Grocery selection Feels like a discounted online grocery store with rotating deals Seasonal produce with a smaller add-on marketplace Primarily fresh produce; fewer pantry-style extras
Ordering model Flexible recurring orders; customize during a shopping window and skip anytime Weekly or biweekly subscription with a produce minimum before add-ons Subscription boxes in several sizes; up to a handful of substitutions per delivery
Organic options Heavy emphasis on organic; non-organic items clearly labeled Conventional and organic harvest options Separate all-organic and all-natural box lines
Minimums & fees Low order minimum; free shipping once you hit a spend threshold, flat fee below it Low produce minimum; free shipping above a modest order total, small fee otherwise Box price generally includes delivery; boxes themselves are pricier than rescued-only services
Food-waste impact Large-scale rescue of “imperfect” and surplus groceries nationwide Each harvest rescues produce and supports hunger-fighting organizations Focus on convenient access to produce; more like a CSA than a food-rescue service
Add-on groceries & extras Robust extras: snacks, baking staples, coffee, wine, and more Plant-based meats, eggs, dairy, grains, snacks, and other basics Recipes and flexible box types; add-ons depend on current menu
Best for Most shoppers who want a one-stop, budget-friendly online grocery with a sustainability mission People in its delivery zones who value local impact and smaller, produce-led boxes Households that love farmers’ market–style produce boxes and predictable weekly deliveries
Editorial stance: Want the most complete package? Choose Misfits Market. Live in Hungry Harvest’s region and love its hunger-relief mission? Go with Hungry Harvest. Prefer a classic farm-box feel shipped to your door? Try Farmbox Direct.

Pick by use-case

Best overall value & reach

Nationwide coverage, big variety, and strong discounts on rescued groceries make Misfits Market our default recommendation.

Shop Misfits Market

Biggest local impact

Hungry Harvest is ideal if you’re in its delivery area and want your subscription to directly support local hunger-fighting programs.

See Hungry Harvest

Best classic farm box

Farmbox Direct is great if you want a traditional fruit-and-veg box that feels like a farmers’ market delivered weekly.

See Farmbox Direct

FAQ

What is “rescued” or “imperfect” produce?
“Rescued” or “imperfect” produce is fruit and veg that might be oddly shaped, slightly off-size, or part of surplus inventory. It’s still fresh and tasty, but might not meet grocery-store cosmetic standards. Misfits Market and Hungry Harvest both buy this food so it gets eaten instead of wasted.
Will I still need to go to the grocery store?
Probably sometimes. These services focus mainly on produce and a rotating mix of staples. Misfits Market comes closest to a full grocery shop, with pantry goods, meat, dairy, and snacks. Hungry Harvest and Farmbox Direct are great for produce, but you’ll likely still visit a store for specialty items or brands.
Are these boxes cheaper than regular grocery stores?
It depends on what you buy and where you live. Rescued-grocery models like Misfits Market and Hungry Harvest often undercut typical supermarket prices on organic produce and certain staples, especially when you hit free-shipping thresholds. Farmbox Direct tends to be more about convenience and variety than rock-bottom pricing, similar to a premium CSA.
Which should I choose?
If you want the best all-rounder with nationwide reach and a full grocery cart, go with Misfits Market. If you’re in its service area and love the idea of supporting local hunger-relief efforts each week, Hungry Harvest is fantastic. If you primarily want a curated box of fruits and veggies that feels like a farmers’ market at your doorstep, Farmbox Direct is a strong choice.

© Latest Update — Clear, honest grocery box comparisons.

We earn a commission when you purchase through our links.